Sunday, March 20, 2011

States of Nature

States of Nature


March 12, 2011


Itard: Wild Boy of Aveyron (1801; 1806)


A. Huxley, Brave New World (1932)



Itard’s work amounts to a theoretical treatise on education - what are we humans naturally, instinctively endowed with?; what is cultural? Even before working with the wild boy who he would name Victor, Itard’s philosophy of education was very constructive. Heading into his venture of educating Victor, he believed that “if a child knows the name of the natural sign of the objects he uses … “yes” and “no” and can use them correctly, then all is not lost” (p.88) and that “hereditary forms of mental retardation are extremely rare” (p.87). No doubt the influence of Philippe Pinel, a psychiatrist who in the late 1700s brought more humane living conditions to inmates of asylums, played a role in the Wild Child’s more or less humane treatment.


Itard wrote, five years after starting his work with Victor, that the development of the physical and the intellectual are simultaneous and their influence reciprocal (p. 152, from Report on Progress: 1806). Evidence for this statement is made plain in the fact that an adolescent’s ability to learn and become socialized is in direct proportion to his history of socialization. It is thought that the Victor had been with his family until the age of about four because he was able to learn, to a certain extent. This speaks to the importance of having a companion early in life (p.91-92). “Man is only made to be by his external circumstances”. (It is even thought, although this is only conjecture, that the Victor was left for dead by his family because he wasn’t developing normally - did he have autism? However, we’ll never know and it may as easily have been that he got lost in the great upheaval and migrations that took place over the years following the French Revolution.


“…he wandered about during the severity of a most rigorous winter, clad only in a tattered shirt. At night he retired into solitary places, approaching, as the day advanced, the neighbouring villages; and in this manner he passed a vagrant kind of life, till the time in which, of his own accord, he sought refuge in a dwelling-house in the Canton of St Sernin.” (p.95). This description convinced me that Mary Shelley had read this treatise before completing Frankenstein (the report being published only a few years before she wrote the book). The following description, man in his most natural possible state: “…a disgusting, slovenly boy, affected with spasmodic, and frequently with convulsive motions, continually balancing himself like some of the animals in the menagerie…” (p.96). I believe that if we were to grow up with animals, we would behave like animals. Itard’s account of Victor’s education magnifies the fact that so much of what we have become is the result of cultural forces that have a very tenuous connection to nature at all. Think of Victor’s reaction to some of the “finer” things in life: “…[he has] a complete aversion towards the object of our pleasures and our factitious wants” (p.99), (namely alcohol and snuff), and he remains profoundly and inextricably tied to his natural surroundings. In Itard’s descriptions of Victor, there are several examples of the melancholic and ecstatic effect that Nature has on the “Savage” (p.104, but one example). And another from Report on Progress: 1806: “He drinks his water standing at the window, eyes turned towards the countryside as if in this moment of sheer delight this child of nature seeks to unite the only two things which remain from his lost freedom, a drink of clear water and the sight of the sun on the countryside”. (p.155)


Like Rousseau, Itard is searching for the real, the authentic, the roots of human nature. By reduction Rousseau is trying to figure out what is natural. Similarly, Itard tries to answer: What are we fundamentally? What is our original/initial ‘equipment’?


It was stressed in class that one should be wary of using statements that include the phrase “Human nature” as they are loaded and can be applied to whatever belief system one may support. Given that, I’d like to revisit some of Rousseau’s writing one day and determine exactly what he thought of humanity in his day and how he believed that humanity would look like if it did stay close to a state of nature. (I cannot believe that he would want humanity to look like Victor, the Wild Boy. What a waste that would be! And to live without snuff!?)


So if Victor is the “bottom line”, “bare-bones” human, how did we leave this very basic state of nature? Several suggestions follow: We, in our primeval state, gave over our sovereignty to a lord or leader who kept us under control so as to keep us from killing one another willy-nilly thus enabling us to progress and to live communally. Rousseau’s idea focuses more on the division of labour, exploitation and property from what I recall. But I am still curious about what Rousseau’s idea of utopia was.


Would such a utopia include and “accept” our wild animal instincts even though they might work against community living? Many of our basic instincts are aggressive in nature. To address some of the questions that came up in seminar: Should Victor have been given a chance to express the “forest culture that he was familiar with” and was he somehow short-changed by Itard in this respect? The thought of the professor in The Lives of Animals came to my mind: She suggests that bats and cats have their own culture. They are batty or catty… “We might not value cats the same way we do humans, but they do have their own thing going on”. Should the same consideration have been given Victor? I think it is clear enough that the very notion is ridiculous. Had this boy been found and had Itard not try to civilize him (or “educate him” or “make him more human”…however you want to describe it), Victor would be worse off and there would be criticisms of Itard to this day. Moreover, this study is not comparable to how Europeans tried to “civilize” the Natives of North America because the Natives had language skills and were socialized in a way that Victor certainly was not.



O Brave New World…


“I think of art, at its most significant, as a DEW line, a Distant Early Warning system that can always be relied on to tell the old culture what is beginning to happen to it.” (Marshall McLuhan (1960s))


Aldous Huxley’s life is fascinating. He covered so much in his years and his curiosity is inspirational. In seminar, I was astounded at how much he had covered in his lifetime. His influence spans continents; his famous and influential friends were many and varied. He was wholistic, if I had to pick one word to sum up his life and philosophy. A proponent of the Gestalt movement (whose principle is "The whole is greater than the sum of its parts") and a member of Esalen (an institute that brings together the philosophies of the East and West and supports the Human Potential Movement), Huxley lived his message: “Give it your all!” What I found most agreeable was that he maintained that one needs to dive into relationships with others in order to delve into and to know one’s self.


Most of us have read Brave New World and understand what the themes are. Just prior to rereading the book this month, I learned that in his essay, Brave New World Revisited, (written in 1958) Huxley states that he’s surprised at the pace that humanity is accelerating towards his vision. I can’t help but wonder what he’d think of humanity today! We all walk around with phones… many are “smart, android phones”; some, iPhones. How do we know there’s no recording device within them where everything we say is catalogued somewhere… perhaps not for today, but maybe for tomorrow. Same thing with Facebook. There is something very dystopian about our time.


Mustafa Mond makes a CHOICE to give up science and to go into “control and management of happiness”. Maybe this is his own route to happiness. Maybe this is the difference, he is happy because he has a level of awareness about his decisions. I was interested in learning that his name likely came from “Mustafa Kemal Ataturk” a Turkish president who was very supportive of universal education for all (including adults and women!) While he was in power the armed forces implemented an extensive program of literacy that Atatürk heralded "The Army of Enlightenment". He personally instructed children and adults in schoolrooms, parks, and other places. Literacy which had been less than 9 percent in 1923 rose to more than 33 percent by 1938. He said “The government’s most creative and significant duty is education.”


US Constitution: “Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Happiness…” No mention of the public. The loss of the tribal connection that we once had between others has us seeking happiness in “something shiny and new”. Consumerism is a simple goal. Not liking uncertainty, this is what draws humanity into the trap. And we increasingly need drugs to live (Soma!)


In Myth of Sisyphus: (p.53) “…the theme of permanent revolution is carried into individual experience. Living is keeping the absurd alive. Keeping it alive is above all contemplating it”. This is just what the people in Brave New World were NOT given opportunity to do! To live on the edge: (p.50) “The danger, on the contrary, lies in the subtle instant that precedes the leap. Being able to remain on that dizzying crest - that is integrity and the rest is subterfuge.” The “exhilaration” or “dizziness” Brave New Worlders get is from Soma; it masks the real experience that should be suffused with awareness.

On Eugenics

In reading background information for Brave New World I found that babies born deaf are necessarily raised differently and in order to learn faster, are schooled with other deaf children. No doubt, many of their friends and contacts are deaf. The society of the deaf insists - and rightfully so - that the deaf community is different and has just as much value in every sense of the word as the non-deaf community. Does this make it right for deaf parents to select for deaf embryos?


I don’t normally buy into slippery-slope arguments (abortion has not resulted in the breakdown of our moral fabric as far as I can tell; in fact the opposite can be argued.) and deaf embryos never possessed the ability to hear in the first place so they have not had anything taken away from them… but if this were done for the deaf, we could conceivably see prospective parents who are amputees, paraplegics or blind demanding the same thing, and why not?


On Happiness


Characters in Brave New World who claim to be “happy” are not far from happy, really, at least from how many people define the word. Many people’s time is filled with meaningless time-wasters to mask the inner discontent with how they spend their time. Perhaps we don’t want to pause and ask ourselves: why are we so busy? Is what I’m doing worthwhile? Does it have meaning? No wonder some of us can finally “breathe” when we’re at work because those 8 hours of time are already “spoken for” - we have little choice but to be there and the time spent at work is not “our” time - it is our employer’s and he is to direct it as he sees fit. Perhaps this is just one of multiple definitions of happiness. Does our obsession with maintaining a state of happiness indicate that we are refusing to become adults? We grow through suffering and hardship but this is something to be avoided at all costs.


"Happiness is not achieved by the conscious pursuit of happiness; it is generally the by-product of other activities." Aldous Huxley (1894-1963).


On that note, “work” is very often used as an excuse: “I can’t do this or that because of work…” For some people, work is an escape, a refuge where we don’t have to focus on ourselves. For such individuals it is easier to be at work than maintain the level of activity needed to hide from themselves, or to actually face themselves. Avoid any thought that might indicate that life lacks purpose and meaning.


Is this the genius of the “Protestant Work Ethic”? Keep working incessantly because in doing just that you are doing God’s work, and God will look favorably on you (and it keeps you from thinking, and even questioning God. If you’re not working you have too much time, and are in the Devil’s workshop).


Friday, March 11, 2011

Absurdity

ABSURDITY
March 9, 2011
Myth of Sisyphus Camus(1942)
Waiting for Godot Beckett
“There always comes a time between contemplation and passion. This is called becoming a man.” (p.81, Myth of Sisyphus)

Thinking of the world’s turmoil at the time of the Myth of Sisyphus’ writing, one can better understand the absurd philosophy of Camus. When considered in this context, the society humanity had constructed must have seemed truly absurd, especially when contrasted with the beautiful existence that could have been. It could have been like the life that Camus was very much attached to, the one he romanticized in The Stranger - that of the Mediterranean sand and Algerian sun. Life must have appeared hopeless and senseless after the barbarism of the Second World War, not to mention during the political instability and threat of annihilation brought on by the Cold War. As beings, we need hope to live. Camus’ philosophy might have been a prescription for Camus himself on how he should live through the turbulent days of his time.

The absurd philosophy pits the human desire for meaning with the fact that the universe remains silent and offers us no answers. Vigilantly keeping this in mind amounts to Camus’ revolt against the universe and its silence! Camus tells us is that we have the power to create our own attitudes and that we can live full lives so long as we stay aware in our opposition to the meaninglessness of existence. If one constantly revolts against the universe - or against his own instinct to understand the inexplicable - and maintains the freedom and passion controllable within one’s grasp, one can live a purposeful life, (even the likes Sisyphus, who repeatedly rolls a stone to the top of the hill). “The Absurd is not in man nor in the world, but in their presence together. For the moment this is the only bond uniting them.” (p.34)

Let’s consider Meursault, from The Stranger, the novella written by Camus around the same time as Myth of Sisyphus: Meursault lives in the moment, without expectation. He does not believe in a God or in anything that is beyond the knowable, the seeable, the here and now. Even though there will always be the mysteries of the universe and of Being and Existence, we can be sure of what we know. Meursault appreciates his life despite the routine and banality of it all. “The opposite of freedom, then, is not a person restrained by the laws of physics, but a person restrained by a repressive government or by his own timidity—earthly, alterable influences. The absurd man is free in this sense because he has abandoned the idea that his life has any value or any meaning, and so does not feel committed to living toward any particular goal. As a result, he faces every new moment free from the constraints of thought and actions that we normally conform to in society.” This speaks very well to Meursault’s actions, presumed mindset and seeming apathy.

Camus says we should give up hope, and then we will be happy. (Much like giving up certain (culturally manufactured) desires would make us happier!) Like what it is that you have to do, then you will be happy (easier said than done!)

Meursault is ensconced in the reality immediately before him. Even though he doesn’t express enthusiastic appreciation for what he experiences, he is more aware than the average person today. Taking things for granted, we do not stop and smell the roses enough. We don’t spend time with or appreciate our friends or even acknowledge the beauty of a child’s smile. We rush through our mornings and our own free time, only feeling at peace once we are at work. This is an interesting juxtaposition. Is this the Protestant work ethic upon us - do we find comfort and meaning in our jobs only because we don’t have to worry about wasting our own precious time as we are “on the clock” and the next 8 hours are spoken for? Living as simply as Meursault, one might imagine his life dull and that living like him would make for days that endlessly drag on. There is lucidity in the way he lives, nonetheless. He knows what he is doing with his own time and needs not the distractions that many people use today, rushing from one triviality to another.

It is as if the rational age we live in multiplies our desire to understand the universe, as if complete understanding (and therefore meaning?) is possible. We have all sorts of knowledge and information that can explain the “little” questions, but humanity - whether we admit it or not - is still as in the dark on the “big” questions as in any time of its existence. (p.43): “The most widespread spiritual attitude of our enlightened age: the one, based on the principle that all is reason, which aims to explain the world”.

In class, I found it interesting that Camus’ philosophy was more negatively received than, say, Aurelius’ Epicurean philosophy given that both hold similar notions. Camus: (p.35) “A man devoid of hope and conscious of being so has ceased to belong to the future.” Aurelius: (Book XII, 1): (p.111), “…if you will be fair to yourself; that is if you leave all the past behind, commit to Holiness and Justice. … If then, when you arrive at last at your final exit, resigning all else, you honour your governing self alone and the divine element within you, if what you dread is not that some day you will cease to live, but rather never to begin at all to live with Nature, you will be a man worthy of the universe that gave you birth, and will cease to be a stranger in your own country, surprised by what is coming to pass every day, as at something you did not look to see, and absorbed in this thing or in that.” Neither believes one should rely on superstition or religion, believe in gods or demons… but to simply deal with the reality at hand. Deal with the world here and now and don’t fuss over what is disprovable. Let’s live what we know and not get hot and bothered over metaphysical absurdities and uncertainties. There is something in the delivery of their messages, though. As stated by Camus, (p.41) “The important thing … is not to be cured, but to live with one’s ailments”. Since life is a terminal condition, a death-sentence as it were, one must not waste time by hoping and praying for deliverance. Aurelius’ delivery is much less forceful, more elegant and less inflammatory. (Camus, again): (p.49) “The absurd is lucid reason noting its limits”.

Godot.
Reading Myth of Sisyphus before Waiting for Godot made for a more enlightening reading. The essence of both works can create anxiety in those who have religious beliefs or those who - consciously or unconsciously - have a gnawing discomfort in their hearts because they somehow feel lost. Often, these people perform pointless duties that fill their lives while they wait for a pointless future that delivers the same as yesterday. Today, these futile ventures might be video games, Facebook, fashion… People do fill decades of life with the silliness, not to say that my life has any more meaning than theirs, as this is all very subjective. But today it is deemed socially normal to bury our heads in the sand in one way or another and for that reason we do it without feeling strange about it. The result, though, is that it distances us from ourselves and from others. There is power in numbers: Seeing how people communicate through social networking sites (to the extent that some do nowadays) would have seemed absolutely sick just a few decades ago, never mind a few years ago! Recall Huxley’s statement: “One’s fantasy is rich and abundant one’s existence is poor, arid and disenchanted. The mind is full but the world one inhabits is empty.”

People waiting for some “saviour” from the external rather than finding something internal, something within. This is one of the diseases of our modern age and it can be glimpsed in various guises in Waiting for Godot, not the least in the sick and dependent relationship between Pozzo and Lucky, who can’t bear living with one another but expect *something* from each other. The play is also a commentary on human memory - we are as ill-bred and oblivious today as we’ve ever been. Our fundamental nature has not changed; we repeat our mistakes over and over… “Plus ca change, plus c’est la meme chose.”

The play is a shell chock-full of archetypes, and we as members of the audience are to fill it in as we see fit. There is a lot of room for analysis and interpretation but it might be difficult to find comfort in such a play. However, some might be comforted (in the same way as Nietzsche suggests was the case in Ancient Greek theatre) because we see ourselves in this play and we don’t feel so alone!

The message I drew from the play, imagining Pozzo and Lucky next to each other, day after day, is that we have each other. Relationships between people is what is important. In the end, this is one thing that really matters (at least to me) and brings fulfillment, happiness, and all those good things.

Thursday, March 3, 2011

Love

LOVE
Plato: Phaedrus
Thomas Mann: Death In Venice

So this week we looked at the topic of “love” but in a cerebral, philosophical sense, not in a “reality TV sense”. Death in Venice is a short but wonderfully dense book about Gustav von Aschenbach, a writer who becomes obsessed with a young boy while vacationing in Venice. Although this might sound rather sick and twisted, it isn’t if you look at it within the context of some of the books we’ve read this semester. It is an account of what happens to this artist’s inner self as a result of seeing (to his eyes, anyway) the embodiment of a pure, divine Form. What must be considered is that Aschenbach is the personification of dry, Western reason. (p.7): “Preoccupied with the tasks imposed upon him by his ego and the European psyche, overburdened by the obligation to produce, averse to diversion, and no lover of the external world and its variety, he was quite content with the view of the earth’s surface that anyone can gain without stirring far from home, and never so much as tempted to venture beyond Europe.” He is the epitome of the Apollonian in contrast to the Dionysian, and although he possesses everything that Western European culture holds dear (fame, brains, wealth, and a Y chromosome) there is something not quite “right” with him: He is fidgety, socially inept, constantly ill-at-ease and off-kilter. I suggest that this is the physical manifestation of the imbalance hinted at above.

Parallels between Aschenbach and Pentheus (from The Bacchae) are strong. Both live straight-edge lives, so much so that when they are infected with the Dionysian they are overwhelmed by its power and are thus ruined. It is as if, by living so distant from and for so long without the Dionysian, they have no resistance to its virulence, are overcome by it and are unable to recover. Pentheus experiences the Bacchic festivities of the satyrs and revelers in the flesh while Aschenbach dreams about them: (p.126) “…a deep spiritual resistance, and, having run their course, leaving his entire being, the culture of a lifetime, devastated, obliterated. It began with fear, fear and desire and a dire curiosity about what was to come. Night reigned, yet his senses were vigilant, for from afar there approached a din…long drawn-out u - (this must be an echo of p.57, where people are calling out T’s name:) “Adgio or, more often, Adgiu, with a final u they lengthened as they called… he found the euphony appropriate to the object in question and, having repeated it to himself, turned back, contented, to his letter and papers.”
(p.127) …smooth-skinned youths prodding he-goats with leafy staffs, clutching their horns, letting themselves be dragged along and whooping at each leap… Great was his repugnance, great his fear, honorable his intention to defend his domain against the stranger, the enemy of the serene and dignified intellect. But the noise … mountainside … and swelled into raging madness.

After this, one might say that Aschenbach has become fully infected and there is no turning back. He has experienced something so foreign and so true to his true nature that he cannot go back to his old humdrum existence. He will forever be searching for this feeling of life that Tadzio and Venice brought him. It was in Venice, really, that his inner self was stirred and his inner voice found. Ironically, this experience of loving and dying amounts to both Aschenbach’s awakening and his death. He, like Pentheus, taps into something that is inherent to his being (the Dionysian) but cannot handle it after a lifetime of suppression.

Phaedrus

The Phaedrus is very similar to the other Platonic dialogues I’ve read in that Socrates’ comments are usually followed by the words “Of course, Socrates!” It was difficult reading, at times, but love, after all, can be complicated:
(p.9) SOCRATES: …whereas those who happened not to be in love, but achieved what they asked through merit, would not begrudge those who associate with the objects of their attentions but would hate those who did not wish to do so, thinking that they were being looked down on by the latter but benefited by the presence of the former, so that there is much greater expectation that the other party will gain friends than enemies from the affair.
Being able to cut up whatever it is again, kind by kind, according to its natural joints, and not to try to break any part into pieces, like an inexpert butcher; as just now the two speeches took the unreasoning aspect of the mind as one form together, and in the way that single body naturally has form together, and in the way that asingle body naturally has its parts in pairs, with both members of each pair having the same name, and labeled respectively left and right, so too the speeches regarded derangement as naturally a single form in us, and the one cut off the part on the left-hand side, then cutting it again and not giving up until it had found among the parts a love that is, as we say, “left-handed”, and abused it with full justice, while the other speech led us to the parts of madness on the right-hand side, and discovering and setting forth a love that shares the same name as the other but is divine, it praised it as the cause of our greatest goods.
PHAEDRUS: Very true.

One of the main ideas explored here is that our reason and our appetites often pull us in different directions. Appetite desires instant pleasure while reason fancies restraint.

p.16 LOVE DEFINED: the irrational desire that has gained control over any judgement urging a man towards what is correct, and that is carried towards pleasure in beauty - in turn being forcefully reinforced by the desires related to it in its pursuit for the beauty of bodies.

What was very surprising to me was how, at times, the beloved was described as having to be inferior to the lover in order to keep the lover satisfied. The purpose of this seemed to be so that the lover could mold the beloved as he saw fit without giving much freedom to the beloved. A dynamic of such a power imbalance in a relationship makes one uncomfortable. Such a relationship wouldn’t work today, but in analyzing how relationships were in the past, we should be careful not to practice “presentism” and impose our own moralities while reading two-thousand-year-old works. In this light, Aschenbach is partly redeemed for falling for a pre-pubescent boy. These two books, Death in Venice and Phaedrus do complement each other very well in this sense. Indeed, there is a meditation on the Phaedrus in Death in Venice and, as has happened so often this year, I wish we had more time to explore these books in relation to each other. This may very well be part of my final project for the course.

Tuesday, March 1, 2011

Violence

All Quiet on the Western Front (1929), Erich Maria Remarque
Arendt - On Violence (1970)

One of my classmates articulated exactly how I felt while reading Hannah Arendt's book. He mentioned that he lacked the context necessary to appreciate On Violence. He, like me, had no background on Arendt before starting the book and felt as though he’d jumped into a conversation that had been going on for a long while without him. This is one of Arendt’s later books so I presume she’s writing to a readership that knows where she’s coming from and has some foundation to stand on.

This book was scheduled to be read at a timely time given the uprisings happening in Northern Africa and the Middle East… this contributed to an already passionate discussion in class.

Nowadays - even compared to when On Violence was written (1969), new technologies aiding the reporting of events worldwide have brought war-ravaged areas to our living rooms in real-time: At the start of the Vietnam war, it took two days for reports to make it to newscasts. By the end of that war, a mere few hours… and in 2001, we watched the twin towers fall, live.

A topic that came up again, in class, was that of aggression and whether it is an instinct or a learned behaviour? My feeling is that if violence weren’t instinctual, then there must have been a time, pre-history, when there was no fighting between humans. Can anyone believe there was such a time??

But the book left me with more questions: Arendt never really addresses where violence comes from if not from an instinct inherent in humans. If violence is an extension of the person, like a dagger is an extension of one’s arm, how can the person and violence be separated? What is more, Arendt was a supporter of the death penalty in certain situations so this is quite a contradiction. I’d be interested in reading what she has to say about this form of punishment.

Interesting, mind-boggling facts: WWI Military deaths: 9.7 M; WWI Civilian deaths: 6.8 M.
WWII Military deaths: 22.5-25.5 M; WWII Civilian deaths: 32-50 M.

The following definitions and quotations would have been useful before probing into the book itself. They are nuggets from which she expands her ideas, sometimes in a very cerebral way.

“The end of human action, as distinct from the end products of fabrication, can never be reliably predicted. The means used to achieve political goals are more often than not of greater relevance to the future world than the intended goals.”
The notion of “luck” on the battlefield is one that has me look with wonder on human history over the 40 years after WWII (Cold War). I can’t help but be amazed that humanity survived that era without a nuclear holocaust - how many times did we come close to that?

A message repeated over by Arendt is that violence and power not only must be differentiated, but that they are polar opposites. “The only way to maintain control in the absence of power is through the continual use of violence. Protracted violence results in diminished power, making more violence necessary.”

“Loss of power leads some to try to replace it with violence. But violence is the opposite of power and cannot stand in its stead.” However, does she provide us with answers or tips as to how we should proceed? Not really, at least not as far as I could read (the reading is dense, I must say… perhaps I missed a thing or two). On p.5, she quotes a passage that is as true today as it ever has been: p.5 “Covenants, without the sword, are but words” (-Hobbes).

p.3 The technical development of the implements of violence has now reached the point where no political goal could conceivably correspond to their destructive potential or justify their actual use in armed conflict … “if either end wins it is the end of both.”

I like the following quote, as it hints toward something pathological in human thought: that of the mere expression of an hypothesis as “truth”; as if the outcome of that hypothesis is the end of a course of action, therefore leaving little or no room for maneuvering. (p.6/7) “The logical flaw in these hypothetical constructions of future events is always the same: what first appears as a hypothesis - with or without its implied alternatives, according to the level of sophistication - turns immediately, usually after a few paragraphs, into a “fact”, which then gives birth to a whole string of similar non-facts, with the result that the purely speculative character of the whole enterprise is forgotten… pseudoscience.”

p.10 …power cannot be measured in terms of wealth - an abundance of wealth may erode power, riches are particularly dangerous to the power and well-being of republics - an insight that does not lose validity because it has been forgotten.

p.17 What are “problems” to us “are built into the flesh and blood of the young.” (speaking of our attitudes… they are formed when we are still young and impressionable.)

p.18 For the future, as Spender puts it, is “like a time-bomb buried, but ticking away, in the present.” To the often-heard question Who are they, this new generation? one is tempted to answer, Those who hear the ticking. And to the other question, Who are they who utterly deny them? the answer may well be, Those who do not know, or refuse to face, things as they really are.

The denial of our death is seen (or not seen, rather!) all around us. Many are known to live their lives without recognizing their inevitable end, and even if they do, they do not change their behaviours accordingly. Could the following be some kind of desire to immortalize the self? p.27 Human development is a form of chronological unfairness, since late-comers are able to profit by the labours of their predecessors without paying the same price, or, in the words of Kant, “It will always remain bewildering … that the earlier generations seem to carry on their burdensome business only for the sake of the latter … and that only the last should have the good fortune to dwell in the [completed] building.”

p.41 “To suppose that majority rule functions only in democracy is a fantastic illusion,” as Jouvenel points out: “The king, who is but one solitary individual, stands far more in need of the general support of Society than any other form of government.”

p.42 “…power always stands in need of numbers, whereas violence up to a point can manage without them because it relies on implements.”
The extreme form of power is All against One, the extreme form of violence is One against All.

p.44-46 – definitions of power, strength, force, authority and violence:

POWER: ability to act in concert. Power is never the property of an individual.

STRENGTH: designates something in an individual entity.

The strength of even the strongest individual can always be overpowered by the many, who often will combine for no other purpose than to ruin strength precisely because of its peculiar independence.
It is in the nature of a group and its power to turn against independence, the property of individual strength.

FORCE: should indicate the energy released by physical or social movements.

AUTHORITY: To remain in authority requires respect for the person or the office. The greatest enemy of authority, therefore, is contempt, and the surest way to undermine it is laughter.

p.45 – when authority leaves, power enters.

VIOLENCE: is distinguished by its instrumental character. Phenomenologically, it is close to strength, since the implements of violence, like all other tools, are designed and used for the purpose of multiplying natural strength.

p.50 Even the totalitarian ruler, whose chief instrument of rule is torture, needs a power basis – the secret police and its net of informers. Only the development of robot soldiers… Single men without others to support them never have enough power to use violence successfully.

p.52 Violence can be justifiable, but it will never be legitimate. Its justification loses in plausibility the farther its intended end recedes into the future.

p.53 Violence can always destroy power; out of the barrel of a gun grows the most effective command, resulting in the most instant and perfect obedience. What never can grow out of it is power.
To substitute violence for power can bring victory, but the price is very high; for it is not only paid by the vanquished, it is also paid by the victor in terms of his own power.

p.55 …effectiveness of terror depends almost entirely on the degree of social atomization. Every kind of organized opposition must disappear before full force of terror can be let lose. This atomization … is maintained and intensified through the ubiquity of the informer, who can be literally omnipresent because he no longer is merely a professional agent in the pay of the police but potentially every person one comes into contact.

The climax of terror is reached when the police state begins to devour its own children, when yesterday’s executioner becomes today’s victim.

p.56 Power and violence are opposites; where the one rules completely, the other is absent.

p.61 …lack of provocation apparently leads to instinct frustration, to “repressed” aggressiveness, which according to psychologists causes a damming up of energy whose eventual explosion will be all the more dangerous. (It is as though the sensation of hunger in man would increase with the decrease of hungry people.)

p.62 …the additional gift of reason makes man a more dangerous beast. It is the use of reason that makes us dangerously “irrational”, because this reason is the property of an “aboriginally instinctual being.” … it is man the toolmaker who has invented those long-range weapons that free him from the “natural” restraints we find in the animal kingdom, and that tool-making is a highly complex mental activity.

p.63 Only where there is reason to suspect that conditions could be changed and are not does rage arise. (injustice!)

p.64 In order to respond reasonably one must first of all be “moved,” and the opposite of emotional is not “rational”, whatever that may mean, but either the inability to be moved … which is a perversion of feeling. Rage and violence turn irrational only when they are directed against substitutes…

p.67 In military as well as revolutionary action individualism is the first value to disappear. … perform an irrevocable action in order to burn his bridges to respectable society…

p.68 …faced collectively and in action, death changes its countenance; now nothing seems more likely to intensify our vitality than its proximity …

p.69 Have not men always equated death with the “eternal rest”, and does it not follow that where we have life we have struggle and unrest? Is not quiet a clear manifestation of lifelessness or decay?

p.74 [perverse biological justification of violence, because it has an urge to grow]

p.80 The practice of violence, like all action, changes the world, but the most probably change is to a more violent world.

p.83 …the present glorification of violence is caused by severe frustration of the faculty of action in the modern world. It is simply true that riots in the ghettos and rebellions on the campuses make “people feel they are acting together in a way that they rarely can.”

p.84 Bigness is afflicted with vulnerability; cracks in the power structure of all but the small countries are opening and widening.

p.86 It is as though we have fallen under a fairyland spell which permits us to do the “impossible” on the condition that we lose the capacity of doing the possible, to achieve fantastically extraordinary feats on the condition of no longer being able to attend properly to our everyday needs.

Thursday, February 10, 2011

Transformation

TRANSFORMATION


Andre Breton: Manifestos of Surrealism (1924, 1929); Nadja (1928)

Franz Kafka: The Metamorphosis (1915)


Manifestos of Surrealism (1924, 1929); Nadja (1928)


"It is living and ceasing to live which are imaginary solutions. Existence is elsewhere."

(Breton)


"To me it seems one of the rarest distinctions that a man can accord to himself if he takes one of my books into his hands..."

(Nietzsche) [But I’m sure Breton would have said the same thing].


Surrealism


It always seemed to me that the Surrealist movement, like its art, can be loosely interpreted based on the observer’s perspective. I don’t think that description of Surrealism is far off the mark. One of its goals is to express the unconscious activity of the mind and this is sometimes done in art by juxtaposing very different images or ideas, thus shocking the mind into thinking beyond its banal and routine ways. The idea is to unhinge the mind so as to open doors into the subconscious. New artistic techniques were developed during this time to unleash the unconscious, a surge of artistic Freudism so to speak. “Frottage” (in art) and other “automatic” techniques (like automatic writing) were very much on the cutting edge of the movement at this time.


The whole concept of human nature became destabilized after the First World War and Surrealism was a reaction to the Enlightenment and the Science that were, in the view of the movement, a buildup to the Great War.


This destabilization of categories and the collapse of ideas onto themselves is made visual in Surrealist Art. Most Surrealist images are surreal, believe it or not, and often to the point of being grotesque.




















For example, I’ve noticed that the landscapes of the Surrealist painters (dreamscapes, they may be called) seem to be unnatural, as if such landscapes could have been caused only by Man, the implication being that Man has perverted Nature, despite the Logic and Rationality that he has held to be divine for so long.


(MOS) p.9 “We are still living under the reign of logic: this, of course, is what I have been driving at. But in this day and age logical methods are applicable only to solving problems of secondary interest.”

Similar to the division and modern imbalance between the Dionysian and the Apollonian, there is an asymmetry with respect to dreams and consciousness.


p.11 “I have always been amazed at the way an ordinary observer lends so much more credence and attaches so much more importance to waking events than to those occurring in dreams. … Thus the dream finds itself reduced to a mere parenthesis, as is the night. And, like the night, dreams generally contribute little to furthering our understanding.”


The juxtaposition of ideas in the art and literature of surrealists may seem far “out there”, but this can be likened to haiku poetry which brings together two very different ideas in a context that makes sense.

p.36 “surrealist images come to him despotically… it does not seem possible to bring together voluntarily what he calls “two distant realities”. The position is made or not made, and that is the long and short of it… I refuse to believe that [examples given] reveal the slightest degree of premeditation…”


Not only does the art tap into the subconscious and stimulate the imagination, but it authenticates individuals by reminding them of a time when they were free from stifling mores of society, not to mention a time of innocence.


p.39 “The mind which plunges into Surrealism relives with glowing excitement the best part of its childhood…To relive those best moments [of childhood] is to experiment once again with the ability to detach oneself from the world as we know it and to find in oneself the freedom to place that given world at a distance Genuine thought goes beyond the limits of a narrow "reality," and that is also why, once its wealth has been rediscovered, there is a risk that it will no longer consent to be mutilated.”


Surrealists tried to meld opposing states, like the conscious and the unconscious, so as to (to use the hackneyed phrase from Jerry Maguire) “complete” humanity.


p.14 “I believe in the future resolution of these two states, dream and reality, which are seemingly so contradictory, into a kind of absolute reality, a surreality, if one may so speak.”


p.123 “Everything tends to make us believe that there exists a certain point of the mind at which life and death, the real and the imagined, past and future, the communicable and the incommunicable, the high and low, cease to be perceived as contradictions. …one will never find any other motivating force in the activities of the Surrealists than the hope of finding and fixing this point.”


p.136 “Let us not lose sight of the fact that the idea of Surrealism aims quite simply at the total recovery of our psychic force by a means which is nothing other than the dizzying descent into ourselves, the systematic illumination of hidden places and the progressive darkening of other places, the perpetual excursion into the midst of forbidden territory…”


Nadja


The works Breton - especially the Manifestos - are great examples of the importance of editing one’s work. Breton might have said that he was tapping into his unconscious and writing through some stream-of-thought stream although he later admitted that there was more thought put into his work than just automatic writing… I questioned Breton from the very beginning of his first Manifesto when he dismisses Crime and Punishment…

p.7 “And the descriptions! There is nothing to which their vacuity can be compared; they are nothing but so many superimposed images taken from some stock catalogue…”

I think Dostoevsky wins the test of time. At least I don’t think Nadja has made it to Oprah’s book club.

When I finally received my second-hand copy of Nadja in the mail, I was rather pissed off to see all the pen markings within it. However, these marks highlighted and annotated important parts allowing me to bypass and cut through Breton’s conceited drivel.


More than a couple of times my inner thoughts spoke directly to Andre and they said, “Get over yourself!”, “Oh, look at you, what a bad boy; you’re such a rebel!”

p.60 “There is no use being alive if one must work.”

p.152/153 “…tried to cover my eyes with her hands in the oblivion of an interminable kiss, desiring to extinguish us, doubtless forever, so that we should collide at full speed with the splendid trees along the road. What a test of life indeed! Unnecessary to add that I did not yield to this desire … I feel less and less capable of resisting such a temptation in every case. I can do no less than offer thanks in this last recollection, to the woman who has made me understand its virtual necessity. In imagination, at least, I often find myself, eyes blindfolded, back at the wheel of that wild car. …as regards love, the only question that exists for me is to resume under all the requisite conditions, that nocturnal ride.” (Whatever.)

p.64 “I took a better look at her. What was so extraordinary about what was happening in those eyes? What was it they reflected - some obscure distress and at the same time some luminous pride? And also the riddle set by the beginning of a confession which, without asking me anything further, with a confidence which could (or which could not?) be misplaced, she made me…” (Enough already)


Much of Breton’s expressed defiance toward authority resembles mere adolescent angst. This is lost on him, though, and he goes so far as to claim a haughty superiority over the rest of society.

p.68 of the common, “unenlightened” people, I suppose: “Naturally they are thinking about what they have left behind until tomorrow, only until tomorrow, and also of what is waiting for them this evening, which either relaxes or else makes them still more anxious.”

What is most annoying is that he rambles on even when he claims that he won’t or that he shouldn’t:

p.50 “I had unusual difficulty shaking off a rather squalid dream which I feel no need to transcribe here…” and yet he does. (His initial reaction was right).

“Life is other than what one writes” … and yet is this not exactly what Breton is doing in Nadja?

p.135 “I virtually fled her presence hoping to find her.” The paradox and complexity of this love story (please make it end)


p.23 “I shall discuss these things without pre-established order, and according to the moment which lets whatever survives survive.”

OK, so now this is close to a definition of Surrealism and as a result of the style’s attempt to cause a convergence of worlds - the conscious with the subconscious, for example - and a unity of all existence, dualities are sometimes seen as fused.


p.136 “I do not suppose there can be much difference for Nadja between the inside of a sanitarium and the outside. There must unfortunately be a difference all the same… on account of the wretched view of the garden, the cheek of the people who question you when you want to be left alone…”


p.142 “…everything leads me to believe that she would have recovered from her wretched state. But Nadja was poor, which in our time is enough to condemn her once she decided not to behave entirely according to the imbecile code of good sense and good manners. She was also alone…”


Kafka: Metamorphosis

The Surrealist society (aside from Breton, the tyrant) might have welcomed Kafka as an adherent and supporter. Although Franz’s world was very small, he always conformed to what society at large - and particularly his own family - asked of him.


His family’s demands were turning Gregor (aka Franz Kafka) into someone, something else (although it might be argued that he always lived his life as a bug. Indeed, is it not his own fault that he is crushed by his bullying father? He’s (literally) spineless.)


Work, modern world - sometimes family, in this case - dehumanizes people, making it very easy to kill them. The German word that Kafka uses to describes what he’s changed into (not a “bug” or a “cockroach”) is similar to “vermin”, but apparently can also be translated as useless, even as a sacrifice (or something to that effect). How the German’s know how to make words. From what little I know about language, my guess is that German is the ideal Surrealist language; it’s a kind of “Lego-language” where very different words can be brought together to (maybe?) set two contrasting images side by side to create a colourful effect.


The fantastic stories of childhood which had us believing in different dimensions were real to us. Gregor awakes from “troubled dreams”. This echoes Atwood’s idea of “unhinged” moments in Payback. Was it during the night that a door between worlds was opened to Gregor, at which point he was transformed into a bug? Was there some alternate reality that he tapped into? Enchantment and the charms of childhood are elicited in this idea and result from this “unhinged moment” making this a surrealist text. (Maybe). What is more, Gregor represents everything that the Surrealists loathed: He is unimaginative, limp-wristed and sycophantic… such people were not part of “Breton’s revolution”).


Why did Kafka chose an apple as the cause of Gregor’s final festering wound? That’s a good question. Please leave comments. (Actually, don’t: I’ve heard from a number of people that they’ve tried to leave comments before but their posts never made it onto the blog page.)


Sunday, February 6, 2011

Repression



























Week 5:

Repression

Heart of Darkness, Joseph Conrad (1899)

Civilization and Its Discontents, Freud (1930)


This week’s pairing of Heart of Darkness with a book by the founder of psychoanalysis gave me a whole new outlook on Conrad’s nebulous novel. Last week our professor intimated that Freud’s work illuminated the darker areas of the human heart, and this got me in the mindset of reading Heart of Darkness as a novel set both in the Congo and deep within the protagonist, Marlow. I could be way off, but it did make the reading more enjoyable than the first time I read the book over a decade ago. At that time I didn’t appreciate the language that described the Congo in an obscure haze, where nothing is as it appears and where not even the characters themselves know what they are doing, why they are doing it or where they are going. (Very much a metaphor for the human race, no?)



The mystery of Kurtz, his plans, his history and his legend are never fully explained, and I viewed this as the ego within that never dies and never accepts the inevitable truth that it will one day no longer be. This pit within all of us makes us believe that we’re somehow different from others, that we are special and immortal. As we age and grow from experience, this element within grows stronger, as does the denial of our impending death. (Remember Rousseau’s statement that one clings to life all the more emphatically when one is in old age?)



(p.100) “‘At this moment I heard Kurtz’s deep voice behind the curtain, “Save me! - save the ivory, you mean. Don’t tell me. Save me! Why, I’ve had to save you. You are interrupting my plans now. Sick! Sick! Not so sick as you would like to believe. Never mind. I’ll carry my ideas out yet - I will return. I’ll show you what can be done. You with your little peddling notions - you are interfering with me. I will return. I…”



This reads like the inner voice of a dying man who has yet to submit to his fate. Is this the wishful thinking of an “Ivan Illych”?


The racism in the book is quite strong. Conrad had less than admirable things to say of Africans, and I will only cite a few examples here:


p.62-64 “No, they were not inhuman. Well, you know, that was the worst of it - this suspicion of their not being human. …the thought of your remote kinship with this wild and passionate uproar.” “…he was an improved specimen.”


“The earth seemed unearthly. We are accustomed to look upon the shackled form of a conquered monster, but there -- there you could look at a thing monstrous and free. It was unearthly and the men were .... No they were not inhuman. Well, you know that was the worst of it -- this suspicion of their not being inhuman. It would come slowly to one. They howled and leaped and spun and made horrid faces, but what thrilled you, was just the thought of their humanity -- like yours -- the thought of your remote kinship with this wild and passionate uproar. Ugly. Yes, it was ugly enough, but if you were man enough you would admit to yourself that there was in you just the faintest trace of a response to the terrible frankness of that noise, a dim suspicion of there being a meaning in it which you -- you so remote from the night of first ages -- could comprehend.”


Moreover, Marlow always refers to black people as “fellows” or “chaps” not “men”. p.35 “Two more bundles of acute angles sat with their legs drawn up.”


Despite all of this, he does seem to recognize the suffering inflicted on the African “fellows” by Europeans:

p.20 “The conquest of the earth, which mostly means taking it away from those who have a different complexion or slightly flatter noses than ourselves, is not a pretty thing when you look into it too much.”


(From Achebe’s essay, “An Image of Africa: Racism in Conrad’s Heart of Darkness”: “Africa is to Europe as the picture is to Dorian Gray -- a carrier onto whom the master unloads his physical and moral deformities so that he may go forward, erect and immaculate.”)


The words suggest the atmosphere of murkiness and confusion of Marlowe’s enterprise; they are quite image and mood provoking:


p.44 “And outside, the silent wilderness surrounding this cleared speck on the earth struck me as something great and invincible, like evil or truth, waiting patiently for the passing away of this fantastic invasion.”


p.59 “…the Eldorado Expedition went into the patient wilderness, that closed upon it as the sea closes over a diver.” “Going up that river was like travelling back to the earliest beginnings of the world, when vegetation rioted on the earth and the big trees were kings.”



The story juxtaposes the old world – England, and civilization – with the “new, barbaric world” of Africa. In a sense, this new world discovery corresponds to the same journey that Freud took started for humanity. Ironically, this world is not so “new,” but taps into our most primitive drives.


p.60 “When you have to attend to things of that sort, to the mere incidents of the surface, reality - reality, I tell you - fades. The inner truth is hidden - luckily, luckily. But I felt it all the same; I felt often its mysterious stillness watching me at my monkey tricks…”



At a fundamental level, each of us is composed of multiple forces, facets of ourselves that, looked at closely enough, make us appear as different people to ourselves. p.82 “These little things [police, European civilization…] make all the difference. When they are gone you must fall back upon your own innate strength, upon your own capacity for faithfulness.”


The language in this book is as dense as the jungle it so often describes. The story itself is not complex although the ideas within it are, and for this reason it is open to interpretation - as open to interpretation as one’s dark heart desires. I just might find out how malleable this book is if it becomes one that I use in writing the essay this term. It seems to be one of those books that one can use to support any possible argument! I’m sure a feminist, a Communist or a Capitalist could shape the ideas of this book into supporting his (or her) cause. However, perhaps to Conrad’s displeasure, it would be hard for a racist to justify racism given how brutally Africans are both described and treated in Heart of Darkness.


Civilization and Its Discontents -

Notes and thoughts:


The theory that Freud was replete with his own neurotic issues and was intelligent enough to rationalize and explain his neuroses is supported in his footnote: “It is remarkable too how regularly analytic findings testify to the link between ambition, fire and urinal eroticism.” (p.35)


I “Ego is originally all-inclusive, but later separates from the external world” - a means of protecting the self against unpleasurable experiences… in the words of Andre Breton, someone who greatly admired Freud, childhood is a time when the imagination is given free reign and is not restricted and minimized by the forces of civilization. When imagination dominates and enchants reality.


p.10 “The origin of the religious temperament can be traced in clear outline to the child’s feeling of helplessness.” And, ironically, depends upon the childish ability to believe in the unbelievable.



II “What we call happiness … arises from the fairly sudden satisfaction of pent-up needs.”


p.15 …another way of stating that *balance* is the key to happiness. Both pleasure and pain need to be experienced to have this appreciation. Talk of excess and the punishment it can bring…


p.17 “One can therefore hope to free oneself of part of one’s suffering by influencing these instinctual impulses.” Aurelius would have agreed! “peace and quiet”


p.22 “Religion interferes with this play of selection and adaptation by forcing everyone indiscriminately its own path to the attainment of happiness and protection from suffering. Its technique consists in reducing the value of life and distorting the picture of the real world by means of delusion; and this presupposes the intimidation of the intelligence.”


p.23 “No other technique for the conduct of life binds the individual so firmly to reality as an emphasis on work, which at least gives him a secure place in one area of reality, the human community. … The great majority work only because they have to, and this aversion to work is the source of the most difficult social problems.” (which must include that of “relations between people” causing stress, grief, frustration…).


III


p.26 Thoughts on technology and how it has not, really, brought pleasure to humanity… “If there were no railway to overcome distances, my child would never have left his home town, and I should not need a telephone in order to hear his voice.” Science: We’ve been given fire and now we’ve run away with it, forgetting where the “tool” came from…


p.32 “The replacement of the power of the individual by that of the community is the decisive step towards civilization.” …but recall Doris Lessing’s critique/warning of “mob mentality.”


“Individual liberty is not an asset of civ.” And Kurtz was trying to start his very own civilization in Africa.


V


Civilization is continually threatened with disintegration because of an inclination to aggression. It invests great energy in restraining these instincts. The law has tried to refine itself to the point of regulating most forms of aggression, but it still fails to prevent it.

Sunday, January 30, 2011

Uncertainty

Frayn: COPENHAGEN (1998)

Is there such a thing as a reliable history of any event? This is one of the main questions brought up by Copenhagen and a reason for the play’s great appeal. As members of the audience we are the jury and can render a verdict on the characters at the play’s end. What the play makes clear is that history - even to the characters involved - is never clear. To paint an historic event as black and white would be to simplify it and to paint a false picture.
One of Copenhagen’s main questions - directly posed three times in the play itself, to Heisenberg himself - is, “Why did Heisenberg visit Bohr in Copenhagen?” Did he pass valuable information to Bohr, thus sabotaging the German war effort? Or vice-versa?

Even within the realm of “Simultaneity” where there is no passage of time, the three main characters cannot reach a consensus as to what actually happened all those years ago, in 1941. Just like humanity looks back on WWII ever since its end, Heisenberg, Bohr and his wife try to make some sense of that time although nothing they learn will make any difference. This indifference can be taken two ways and is true on two counts: 1) We cannot change the past, and 2) Humans will never learn from their mistakes; they are ruled by their aggression and have a long way to go before they can control it on a universal scale.

Characters in any play can be regarded as over- or underdetermined. Great playwrights create complex characters that bring audiences back for more. Hamlet is an ideal example of such a character. Depending on an actor’s delivery of Hamlet’s lines, his words can intimate different things. As an audience, we can never quite determine Hamlet’s motivations or figure out his ambiguities. The uncertainty principle in this play plays into the scientific and the everyday spheres. There is always uncertainty in understanding human conduct. From the outside perspective, we are all underdetermined. Often from within, people can view themselves this way too. Heisenberg, by the end of the play, can still not say why he went to Copenhagen; what he set out to accomplish by going there; who he wanted to serve by going there, as though here were being thrown about by some external force.
Heisenberg inhabits a nexus of sorts. He is pulled between the outcome of a world war, his friendship and respect for Bohr, German politics, and the worry of unleashing a powerful new weapon on mankind, none of which is a small burden to bear.

Classical physics has done humanity well until the twentieth century, giving us the ability to predict and understand the world with a presumption of certain physical conditions. The “Copenhagen Interpretation” is a truer model of both the actual physical world and of how one can understand human interactions. At the heart of many matters, nothing is certain. The difference between the two outlooks can be likened to groups of stars viewed from earth compared to the reality experienced by those stars: the stars as we seem them from earth appear to move apart in two-dimensional space, but they are really pulled apart in 3 dimensions with ever-changing magnitudes of the forces on them, colossal forces from within and from without.

In hindsight, whatever actually took place at this reunion in Copenhagen (just like the measurement of the position of an electron within an atom) is neither here nor there. Historically, it’s immaterial as nothing can be done to change it. What we can appreciate, though, is that history’s characters and their relationships with each other are more an intricate interlacing of fault lines than a clear and definitive one. Such is the nature of true fault lines, and yet most of us envision them as simple geological structures, for the sake of simplicity.

Science is a wonderful thing. It has enabled humanity to do things that we, as spectators and participants, marvel at. The last century (never mind the last quarter century) has witnessed an acceleration of scientific “progress” that would have stunned our ancestors. I’m sure many of them would think that we’d be better off without most of the knowledge we now possess.
In Copenhagen the late 1920s are portrayed as Bohr and Heisenberg’s scientific salad days when camaraderie, rivalry, brotherly love and respect all comingled at the cutting edge of science, without thought of any consequences. As seen throughout the play, though, it is all about perspective: Margrethe is resentful of the toll that Bohr’s research had on their family, and this comes out (p.57) when Bohr is unable to recall his son’s name.
From those beginnings sprung Heisenberg’s obsession, and eventual madness (p.50-52), with nuclear power as the script was flipped on him: (p.51) Bohr: “You were no longer running that programme, H. The programme was running you.”
Heisenberg: “Two more weeks, two more blocks of uranium and it would have been German physics that achieved the world’s first self-sustaining chain reaction.” Bohr, perhaps because he had no role in the race to build a bomb was and remains more rational than Heisenberg. During the war, Heisenberg, and Bohr to a lesser extent, couldn’t locate their own selves because of the speed at which the war and science were moving.

(p.29) Heisenberg: “Mathematics becomes very odd when you apply it to people. One plus one can add up to so many different sums…”
This quote sums up the complexity of all the characters in this play - and of all humanity. We are such multifaceted beings that we still cannot understand ourselves, what moves us, what drives us to do what we do.

p.69-70 H. “Exactly where you go as you ramble around is of course completely determined by your genes and various physical forces acting on you. But it’s also completely determined by your own entirely inscrutable whims from one moment to the next. So we can’t completely understand your behaviour without seeing it both ways at once, and that’s impossible. Which means that your extraordinary peregrinations are not fully objective aspects of the universe. They exist only partially, through the efforts of me or Margrethe, as our minds shift endlessly back and forth between the two approaches.”
Heisenberg sums up the difficulty of understanding anyone - their intentions, motivations and anything they might be thinking. This is subjective and depends on the person who is interpreting the other. It also poses questions regarding the fields of biography, autobiography as well as history).

Recollections are reorganized, consciously or unconsciously, as time goes by, to fit our changed perceptions of a situation, and no doubt Heisenberg did the same. (p. 118)

Uncertainty, at the end of the day, is what makes life interesting anyway. Interpreting the goings-on of our humanity is “tantalizingly difficult” and an inescapable dimension of life. Let’s hope this verity doesn’t hold back our self-understanding so long so as to let our common sense lose in its race with our scientific advancements.

Would Nietzsche have said that the world came to this heated stage as a result of the absence of the Dionysian in our modern lives?


The Stranger - Camus (1942).

Very candid, very frank with little tact. Autistic-like. Example, p.44, 52-53 - asks if he lovers Marie.
The descriptions, especially at first, are very unemotional and simple - just like his emotional development seems to be. His descriptions are two-dimensional, as though being pasted onto a canvas. Near the end, as he is awakened by the knowledge of his impending death, the language becomes more elaborate.

Meursault can appear cold and uncaring - but why do we view him this way? Not everyone has a deep and meaningful relationship with their mother. Moreover, one could say that he is more grounded than the average person because he remains aware that death is inevitable, inescapable. What is curious, though, is that he thinks of the tiny consequences of wasting time at work, perhaps because the consequences of doing so are immediate and avoidable. This is a sociopathic trait: the subject only thinks of immediate consequences for himself and does not think too far into the future… an argument could be made that Meursault has such leanings.

Meursault can be likened to Rousseau’s “natural man”. He does not “play the game” and is without social conditioning. His biggest crime is his lack of conformity and in not playing into society’s expectations. For this he is condemned. Camus might be saying that such a life is the essence of freedom, but that the surrounding life is absurd.

Reason vs Passion; Dualities in the story abound - but Meursault exists in a Central reality, living his own life.

Is the fact that the killed Arab, his sister and their family are never mentioned an indictment on European and colonialist attitudes? Similar to Conrad’s Heart of Darkness (where Africans are portrayed as subhuman) there is a disconnect between the white and the non-white.